StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Stanford Prison Experiment - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "The Stanford Prison Experiment" tells taht the psychologist creates a simulation of prison and recruits a group of both prisoners and prison guards. The same is the case in Plato’s The allegory of the cave in which he observed the behaviour of people in relation to their environments…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92% of users find it useful
The Stanford Prison Experiment
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Stanford Prison Experiment"

Critique of The Stanford prison experiment In his experiment, The Stanford Prison Experiment, Philip Zimbardo strives to prove the effects that societal stereotypes and environments have on human behavior. The psychologist creates a simulation of a prison and recruits a group of both prisoners and prison guards. His observation of the groups shows changes in the behavior of both the guards and the prisoners. The same is the case in Plato’s The allegory of the cave in which he observed the behavior of people in relation to their environments. The roles on the other hand limit the reality that people experience thereby influencing the formation of both their behavior and understanding of reality. The change in the behavior of Zambrano’s participants is systematic and proves his claim that personal roles often change behaviors. Behaviors arise from people’s interaction with their immediate societies. As such, the roles coupled with the beliefs that the society has on such roles systematically influence the behavior of the people playing the role as the discussion below portrays. Both Plato and Zimbardo create an illusionary society by removing their subjects from the society to a new restricted space. While in the spaces, the perceptions of the subjects change based on their understanding of the surrounding. Zimbardo for example sought to establish whether the brutality in American prisons was a result of the guard’s sadistic personality or arose from the prison environment. He therefore recruits his subjects randomly from the society. The participants were normal individuals but without any prior engagements with prisons. As the participants spent more time in the prison environment, their behaviors began to change with the guards becoming increasingly aggressive in their behavior and brutal as they handle the prisoners. The prisoners on the other hand become increasingly submissive to the authority.in his study, Plato criticizes political structures and their effects in indoctrinating people thus influencing their beliefs and social understanding. “On the other hand, The Allegory of the caves is a discussion of politics: The Republic, from which it is taken, is a treatise on justice and the ideal government” (Plato 2). The limited space in the prison restricts the mindsets of both the prisoners and the guards especially when within the premises. The prisoners spent most of their time talking about the prison and prison life. Additionally, their prior understanding of prisons influenced their stories. The same is the case with the guards who become harsh and brutal owing to their belief that guards in prisons are always harsh and brutal to their prisoners. Zambrano’s findings in the detailed research is effective since it explains inherent human behavior and the fact that behaviors are social concepts that depending on the social construction of the various roles people play in their private lives. Another equally important demographic factor about the subjects in the research was their personalities. The fact that all the guards acquired new behaviors by becoming both harsh and brutal including some with multiple personalities was unique and strange to the study. In his separate study, Plato investigates the process of acquiring knowledge and such personality features as courage. In the study, Plato uses the case of a cave with people who live in the cave all their life. The group has no knowledge of the outside world. They comprehend the features based on the features of the cave and the shadows dangling on the roof of the cave. When released from the cave, the people react differently to the sun, trees and people among other living things. The people earn different based on their understanding of the world given the limited space of the cave. The research is symbolic and explains that the process of acquiring knowledge is always progressive beginning with the lower stages to the higher stages of knowledge acquisition. Every stage influences the process of acquiring knowledge. The relationship between the two studies is integral since Zimbardo investigates the development of human behaviors, which relies on the knowledge that people have about their environments. The brutality of prison guards in the United States is not only a stereotype but also a common knowledge in the society. As such, the participants in the study enlisted to the study while well aware of the nature of the relationship that exists between the guards and the prisoners. Their previous understanding of the two positions therefore influences their behavior while in the prison. The guards immediately become brutal towards the prisoners who also become both submissive and cooperative with the guards. Their understanding of the behavior was progressive as Plato explains in his separate study. Knowledge influences behavior change. However, the state often regulates the knowledge. “Then, I said, the business of us who are the founders of the state will be to compel the best minds to attain the knowledge which we have already shown to be the greatest of all. They must continue to ascend until they arrive at the good; but when they have ascended and seen enough we must not allow them to do as they do now” (Plato 5). The outcome of Zimbardo’s experiment proved that the social stereotypes have serious ramifications in the formation of behaviors. While Zimbardo planned for the experiment to take two weeks, it lasted six days. Most of the participants in the study developed serious psychological issues most of which would have lasting effects on them. Some of those playing the roles of prisoners developed serious psychological problems thus forcing Zimbardo to stop the experiment. Strange torturous environments have such effects on people and may always lead to permanent disruptions on the growth and developments of the people. Plato contends with the explanations as he establishes in his own study. The participants in his study also experience difficulty adjusting to the real life soon after they leave the cave. The new society presents them with myriad challenges since it requires an expansion of their mindsets. They struggle to comprehend the prevailing social features and realities most of which contradict with their previous understanding of the universe. They therefore face myriad difficulties and require the assistance of other normal people in order to fit perfectly into the new society and to understand its features as well. In retrospect, the development of behavior is a social process that relies on numerous factors. Key among such factors is the role that people play and the stereotypes associated with such roles. The guards in the experiment acquired authority over the prisoners. They therefore try to live as if actual guards based on their understanding of the relationship between guards and the prisoners. They become bully, brutal and sadistic towards the prisoners who become submissive and loyal. Additionally, the prisoners live in groups and form their own gangs while in the prisons thus creating a type of order unique to such settings. The experiment portrays the importance of knowledge about a role in influencing the behaviors. The systematic change in the behavior of the participants in the research is systematic to the change in the behavior of the participants in Plato’s experiment who depict the progressive process of acquiring knowledge and courage among other personality features. Works cited Plato. The Allegory of the caves. Oxford: OUP, 1922. Print. Zimbardo, Philip. Stanford prison experiment. Washington, DC: Office of Naval Research, 1971. Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Critique Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words - 13”, n.d.)
Critique Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words - 13. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1665842-critique
(Critique Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words - 13)
Critique Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words - 13. https://studentshare.org/english/1665842-critique.
“Critique Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words - 13”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1665842-critique.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Stanford Prison Experiment

Out-of-class Activities The Stanford Prison Experiment

The Stanford Prison Experiment was one of the most controversial experiments that were terminated prematurely due to the moral implications it carried.... The Stanford Prison Experiment was one of the most controversial experiments that were terminated prematurely due to the moral implications it carried.... REACTION PAPER ON stanford prison experiment Name Professor Subject Date Reaction Paper on stanford prison experiment.... REACTION PAPER ON stanford prison experiment Reaction Paper on stanford prison experiment....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Psychology

We are going to answer specific questions about The Stanford Prison Experiment with various details and focus our attention on its ethical sides and outcomes having an interest in social psychology.... We are going to answer specific questions about The Stanford Prison Experiment with various details and focus our attention on its ethical sides and outcomes having an interest in social psychology.... In this part of the paper it is necessary to discuss the results of The Stanford Prison Experiment and explain why it influences people in such a stress way....
2 Pages (500 words) Personal Statement

Analysis of the Stanford Prison Experiment

Analysis of The Stanford Prison Experiment The Article The article under review is the article titled “Another look at Banuazizi and Movahedi's analysis of The Stanford Prison Experiment.... To this effect, it must be stated that the Standard prison experiment was undertaken in the year 1971 at the Stanford University.... The population that was studied The population of the study was made up of middle class and white; sample of whom were selected for the actual experiment....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Article Critique / Theory and Practice of Corrections

Article Critique Philip Zimbardo's article, “Revisiting The Stanford Prison Experiment: A lesson in the power of situation,” focuses on how a situation can alter the mental and emotional capabilities of even the most headstrong individual.... Article Critique Philip Zimbardo's article, “Revisiting The Stanford Prison Experiment: A lesson in the power of situation,” focuses on how a situation can alter the mental and emotional capabilities of even the most headstrong individual....
3 Pages (750 words) Book Report/Review

Stanford Prison Study

The Stanford Prison Experiment was a psychological study conducted at Stanford University and aimed at finding out the causes of disagreements between prisoners and prison warders.... ? The Stanford Prison Experiment was a psychological study conducted at Stanford University and aimed at finding out the causes of disagreements between prisoners and prison warders.... (You may use your book) The ethical consideration of The Stanford Prison Experiment included informed consent since the students volunteered to participate....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Zimbardo's experiment

The more “powerful” prison guards became sadistic day by day while The plight was shown clearly in the “stanford prison experiment” video.... The original experiment was set up for 2 weeks however it had to be stopped abruptly in 6 days because the participants suffered psychologically.... There are a few ethical concerns regarding this psychological experiment.... Firstly, the participants were not informed about the experiment appreciably since Zimbardo himself was unaware how stressful the experiment could become hence the consent of the participants was not fully informed....
3 Pages (750 words) Assignment

Revising the Stanford Prison Experiment: A lesson in the Power of situation, by Phillip G. Zimbago

The Stanford Prison Experiment has several aspects that are similar to the Abu Ghraib Situation and other that are different.... Both happened in controlled setting, a prison, only that the stanford prison was not a real prison whereas the Abu Ghraib situation took place in a real detention centre.... The guards in the stanford experiment and the captors in the Abu Ghraib situation coerced prisoners.... One of the differences between the two cases is that while the stanford experiment used male prisoners only, Abu Ghraib prisoners were both male and female....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

Stanford Prison Experiment

The Stanford Prison Experiment was an official study conducted in 1971 on the campus of Stan-ford University.... This research named "stanford prison experiment" help better understand the unique dynamics of human behaviour that take place between prisoners and prison guards.... The experiment itself was completed by a team researchers, all under the direction of Philip Zimbardo.... The experiment itself was designed to induce a certain level of disorientation, depersonalization, and deindividualization within each participant, and this was actually exceeded in the initial observation of the study....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us