StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Sin Taxation: Legal, Economic, and Moral Justifications - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay "Sin Taxation: Legal, Economic, and Moral Justifications" focuses on the critical analysis of the argument that although sin taxes, including vice and fat taxes, are inherently regressive because they disproportionately burden those least able to afford them…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96% of users find it useful
Sin Taxation: Legal, Economic, and Moral Justifications
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Sin Taxation: Legal, Economic, and Moral Justifications"

Download file to see previous pages

Yet the temptation to impose taxes is one driven by economic reasons and has proven to be very lucrative and worthwhile. In 2010, the government increased its revenue by over $75 billion through sumptuary taxes. As a result, sumptuary taxation is quickly becoming the tax of choice among federal and state authorities and has even gained approval from many taxpayers. Its popularity appears due not only to its money-making abilities but also to its dual purpose. First, it is an efficient way for the government to collect revenue from taxpayers for something they can and probably should live without. Second, unlike other taxes, sumptuary taxes are often enacted with the additional aim of reducing or eliminating the public’s consumption of a particular product. Although economists doubt that sumptuary taxes will greatly affect the behavior of most individuals, especially because the amounts tacked on are quite small, these taxes are an effective source of revenue. Because they attach to the sale of items that some taxpayers will buy no matter how much they cost they make the supply and revenue stream of these items inelastic. As an added social benefit, some of the revenue can go toward funding programs that promote a healthy lifestyle.

Part two briefly reviews the history of sumptuary law and the evolution of the sin tax. This part discusses how sumptuary taxes have emerged into different categories, and examines how the government uses these taxes to generate revenue and fill in their budget gaps. Additionally, part two examines how other countries have successfully levied the different sumptuary taxes to benefit their society as a whole; it also argues the economics of sin taxes is an effective source of revenue because they attach to the sale of items that some taxpayers will buy no matter how much they cost, making them inelastic. Part three analyzes the rationale and public policy in support of sin taxes and raises counterarguments. Additionally, part three addresses the conflict of interest created by a state’s dependence on sin tax revenues and briefly examines a resolution, i.e., earmarking, to mitigate the conflict. Lastly, this paper concludes with how sin taxes are important and why they will benefit society as a whole.  

There is a sound tax policy in implementing sin taxes and placing them on indulgences. Indeed, much of society would agree that you have to "pay to play." Sin taxes have become a popular remedy for states as they deal with budget deficits. Because they are viewed as a discretionary tax (only paid based upon actual use), governmental decision-makers often view increasing them as the path of least resistance among voters. In effect, sin taxes are taxes that are absorbed in the purchase price of an item, as compared to a sales tax, which is paid above the purchase price. They are flat, in that everyone who purchases the item or service pays the same tax regardless of income. There are several justifications for sin taxes, including that demand for harmful products is relatively inelastic and therefore a stable source of revenue, and that the price increase caused by taxing the harmful product reduces its consumption and encourages a healthier lifestyle. Equally important, sin taxes force users of harmful products to internalize the cost of those products rather than spread it across society; therefore, everyone who buys these products pays these taxes, regardless of whether they pay income taxes. Moreover, these taxes can be used to subsidize or fund a special project, at the same time that they discourage the consumption of the targeted vice. Thus, through sin taxes, the government can boost its revenue and reduce the negative impact of these vices in the community.

The tax system is a proven method for raising revenue to finance the goods and services that the government provides and taxpayers enjoy and use. Indeed, "Taxation aims to reduce private consumption and private investment so that the government can provide social goods . . . without causing inflation or balance of payment difficulties." Historically sin taxes were called sumptuary taxes. Sumptuary taxes (Sumtuariae Leges in Latin) date back as far as the ancient Greeks and Romans, who used sumptuary laws as a form of governance. However, through the centuries these laws have evolved. Through sumptuary laws, the Romans attempted to regulate habits of consumption to restrain luxury or extravagance, particularly inordinate expenditures on apparel, food, and furniture. The tax thus reinforced social hierarchies and morals. The Greeks used sumptuary laws specifically to curb conspicuous consumption at funerals by regulating their size and the value of food that could be served at them. Indirectly but deliberately, this also restricted the role of women at funerals. Women were limited to three mourning shawls and were forbidden to wear any kind of make-up or perfumes. In England during feudalism, sumptuary laws were similar to those in ancient Greece, targeting conspicuous consumption, though not specific to funerals, in matters of dress and ornamentation. It was clear that sumptuary discourse was closely linked to the discourses surrounding ‘luxury,’ which itself exhibited a close interweaving of economic and theological controversies.

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“A seminar/law paper that is on vice/sin taxes and how the government Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1393870-a-seminar-law-paper-that-is-on-vice-sin-taxes-and
(A seminar/law Paper That Is on vice/Sin Taxes and How the Government Essay)
https://studentshare.org/law/1393870-a-seminar-law-paper-that-is-on-vice-sin-taxes-and.
“A seminar/law Paper That Is on vice/Sin Taxes and How the Government Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1393870-a-seminar-law-paper-that-is-on-vice-sin-taxes-and.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Sin Taxation: Legal, Economic, and Moral Justifications

Evaluate economic, legal and ethical impacts on the quality of healthcare provided to patients

This paper seeks to evaluate the effects of ethical, economic and legal factors, that affects the quality of medical services delivered to patients in health institutions.... he ultimate aim of addressing these ethical, economic and legal issues and improving the conditions under which patients receive treatments.... This assessment is investigating a major hypothesis and claim by patients from various health centers that: The mistreatments and the violation of the fundamental freedoms of patients to access medical services is influenced by the prevailing economic, ethical and legal factors....
15 Pages (3750 words) Research Paper

Is America a Christian Nation

Approved by the new secular philosophy these concepts of “natural man”, his “natural state”, his “natural rights” are understood beyond the divine and moral dimension.... These differences come to the fact that in Christianity these considered values have an absolute divine source, and thus are endowed with an absolute moral dimension; in the liberal paradigm all these values have only human, relative and conventional sources, and thus lacking absolute moral dimension....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

Are we violating the human rights of patients in a persistent vegetative state

data that would offer clue to the validity of the assumption made, we have looked into an extensive array of Literature sources that contain anecdotal references to different issues connected with this medical problem: the very definition of Other research objectives identified are: signs and symptoms, causative factors, legal preliminaries, etc.... These case studies have gone into the depth of how and why it is necessary to have proper legal safeguard mechanisms to avoid human rights violations, because of various controversies that are inseparable from the very findings of PVS....
80 Pages (20000 words) Essay

The Morality of Shared Responsibility

The individual may additionally bear moral responsibility for the transgressions of their government; a moral responsibility that can be passed down through the generations.... Alternatively, they may be forced to compensate the victims of government abuse through a system of coerced taxation....
17 Pages (4250 words) Essay

The Prevalence of Alcohol Consumption in Adults

The rise is consumption is though due to social issues, but the economic conditions of the Australians have also contributed towards this increase.... Unless the government is not successful in the resolution of issues relevant to social and economic needs of the people, the emotional and psychological desperation will prevail, Through this study we have surveyed the opinion of people towards the legislation specific to alcohol consumption control....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Should Sex Workers Be Considered Employees

As a result, she was not an employee but rather, self-employed and assumed all economic risks with respect to her earnings.... The paper "Should Sex Workers Be Considered Employees?... discusses post-modern liberal feminists' argument prostitution represents an expression of female power....
17 Pages (4250 words) Essay

Protestant Reformation

This essay discusses that during the 16th century the great reformer Martin Luther spread his teachings of Lutheranism which is one of the branches of Protestantism.... By the 18th century, Lutheranism spread to many countries such as America, Germany and many other parts of the world.... ... ... ...
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

For Capital Punishment

his paper will discuss the question of crime and punishment in the context of legal issues and jurisprudential perspective.... Is the legal system of the United States already and cleared of flaws that capital punishment must be imposed, and what should only be debated now is the question of morality?... e will discuss in this paper some interesting topics on capital punishment touching on the legal issues, the relation of law to morality, the nature of legal rules and legal concepts, the nature of judicial decision making, relation of law to the social sciences, and the eighth amendment....
30 Pages (7500 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us