StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

A Comparison of Probation and Parole - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper "A Comparison of Probation and Parole" focuses on the specific terminologies used in the criminal justice system that require a closer analysis for the ordinary layman to understand. Two of the commonly used terms are probation and parole. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.3% of users find it useful
A Comparison of Probation and Parole
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "A Comparison of Probation and Parole"

A Comparison of Probation and ParoleThere are specific terminologies used in the criminal justice system that require a closer analysis for ordinary layman to understand. Two of the commonly used terms are probation and parole. The official website of the Bureau of Justice Statistics (BJS) defined probation as period of time where “adult offenders whom courts place on supervision in the community through a probation agency, generally in lieu of incarceration” (par. 1); while parole is defined, likewise, as period of time where “criminal offenders …are conditionally released from prison to serve the remaining portion of their sentence in the community” [Burnd].

From the definitions, it could be deduced that probation and parole share similarities in terms of serving time periods outside of incarceration, usually in the community; but differ in terms of time of application, where “probation occurs prior to and often instead of jail or prison time, while parole is an early release from prison” [Adv142].There are similarities between probation and parole in terms of influencing behavioral changes and serving the best interests of the community, to wit: “both are concerned with a defendant breaking the bad habits or behaviors that caused them to break the law.

Even though both probation and parole have a strong rehabilitation component, each process has the additional goal of protecting the community” [Adv142]. Likewise, both involved supervision statutes that require, either active or inactive supervision, depending on the severity of the offense and on other mitigating factors [Burnd].On the other hand, the disparities between probation and parole are diverse. At the onset, through definition, the time of application spelled major difference where probation is recommended prior to incarceration; while parole is dispensed after some time has been served in jail.

In addition, the supervising officers are different: a probation officer for the former and a parole officer for the latter. Also, conditions or subsequent changes in probation are noted to be within the jurisdiction of the court [Adv142]; while parole changes and conditions were reportedly set by the parole board [Adv142]. Concurrently, in terms of purpose or function, although both were noted to share similarities in behavioral intent and aiming to reduce the impact as well as incidence of crime in society, offenders who were given parole would face challenges in terms of reintegration due to the social stigma associated with criminal offenders who had been incarcerated.

Whereby criminal offenders perceive probation as an optimistic alternative to incarceration, those who were given opportunities for parole had already served a defined sentence in jail; as such, the outlook for immersion in the community would already contain the stigma of criminal conviction. Appendix 1 presents a tabular illustration of the comparative analysis between probation and parole in terms of function, goals, historical development, current challenges, and treatment theories.Overall, the current discourse has clearly presented similarities between probation and parole in terms of application of serving time and behavioral intent as well as serving the interests of society.

The disparities were noted to be varied from supervising officers, statutes, as well as governing changes and conditions. Despite their differences, both probation and parole are still seen as alternatives to incarceration, which, bring hope for a postive and productive life for the offenders.Works CitedBurnd: , (Bureau of Justice Statistics par. 1), Adv142: , (Advice Company par. 1), Adv142: , (Advice Company par. 8), Burnd: , (Bureau of Justice Statistics), Adv142: , (Advice Company), Ala15: , (Alarid 28), Ala15: , (Alarid 55), Appendix 1: Comparative Analysis – Probation versus ParoleProbationParoleFunctionTo “assist in reducing the incidence and impact of crime” [Ala15]For economic reasons; to reintegrate offender to society [Adv142].

GoalsProtect the interests of the public “by reducing the incidence and impact of crime” [Ala15].“to ease crowded facilities, to save money, and to reintegrate offenders” [Ala15].Historical developmentOrigins in 1700s and 1800s as alternatives to incarceration for children“work of penal reform-ers in Germany, Spain, and France as well as that of Alexander Maconochie on Norfolk Island” [Ala15]Current challengesSupervision statutes [Burnd]Supervision statutes [Burnd]Treatment theoriesCasework model, brokerage of services model, community resource management team model, justice model, neighborhood based supervisionMedical model, “indeterminate sentencing philosophies of the 1930s with the justice model and determi-nate sentencing in the 1970s” [Ala15]

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“A Comparison of Probation and Parole Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1652198-compare-and-contrast-probation-and-parole
(A Comparison of Probation and Parole Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/law/1652198-compare-and-contrast-probation-and-parole.
“A Comparison of Probation and Parole Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1652198-compare-and-contrast-probation-and-parole.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF A Comparison of Probation and Parole

Arrested for Murder in Dublin, Ireland

Different countries across the globe have laws that govern criminal liabilities like murder, manslaughter and rape and most of these are defined by legislations made by the parliament.... Ireland, a country which part of the United Kingdom has some of the most refined and clear… Suspect handling before they are taken to court is an essential phase in any legal system and may determine the admissibility of a number of evidences Murders in most countries attract different punishments and this is mostly influenced by the circumstance under which the murder was actually committed....
13 Pages (3250 words) Research Paper

Effective Treatment for Incarcerated Addicts

Both home confinement and drug and alcohol medication may be a state of pretrial discharge, of probation or a piece of a master gram that permits early discharge from penitentiary.... The report "Effective Treatment for incarcerated addict" is about incarcerated addicts or in other words, addicts who are haven given the order the order to remain confined either with their family or the state prison....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

How Mediation Can Serve Worker's Compensation

In all programs however, the first step begins with the referral of an offender to the program, which is usually done by victim assistance staffers or prosecutors or parole officers or judges.... These are church-based programs, community-based programs, probation–based or system-based programs and dispute settlement centers....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Removing Hurdles of Management

The paper “Removing Hurdles of Management” will seek to engage the reader with an understanding of how management can best be affected in terms of the proposed expansion of Rohan within the nation of Oman as well as a level of unified and uniform training of the employees.... hellip; The author suggests that Burn's theory of leadership as such would indicate that stakeholders within management should either practice a transactional form of leadership or a transformational leader....
4 Pages (1000 words) Case Study

Probation and Parole vs. Incarceration - Cost Comparison

parole on the other hand, refers to law offenders who are conditionally released from prison to serve the remaining term of their sentence in the community.... The offenders may be released by a parole board decision (Bureau of Justice Statistics, 2015).... These costs arose upon conviction and subsequent imprisonment for parole prisoners.... million convicts imprisoned in the jails and state prisons are imprisoned for parole violations....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Common Perception of Juvenile Offenders

For example under the law of Minnesota, a punishment for trying crack cocaine is four years of confinement, while trying powdered cocaine leads only to probation period.... Still, the other reason for such misbalance was also caused by the difference in attitude to black or latin juveniles in comparison to white ones....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Penal Code in the State of Illinois

This paper 'The Penal Code in the State of Illinois" focuses on the fact that the Illinois penal code enforces laws and outlines sentencing procedures for individuals accused of committing a crime.... In contrast to a misdemeanour, felony court maintains high standards in enforcing laws.... nbsp; … As by definition felonies constitute one or more years in prison....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Race and Justice Department

he next important aspect that one should focus on is the institute of parole and the way it affects the minorities.... The statistic shows that the number of African Americans on parole is compared to the number of their white counterparts as 2 to 1 (Motivans, 2015).... Indeed, it was found that African Americas are almost twice as likely to use drugs while being on parole as whites (Motivans, 2015).... In addition to that, the probability that a black person is likely to violate the rules of parole while committing a new crime is even higher: two and a half times more than whites....
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us