StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Contemporary British Politics and Contemporary Political Ideologies - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author of the essay "Contemporary British Politics and Contemporary Political Ideologies" states that Prime Minister has suggested that some of his power under the royal prerogative should be transferred to Parliament. This has led to renewed calls for a written constitution for the UK…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.3% of users find it useful
Contemporary British Politics and Contemporary Political Ideologies
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Contemporary British Politics and Contemporary Political Ideologies"

Prime Minister has suggested that some of his power under the royal prerogative should be transferred to Parliament. This has led for renewed calls for a written constitution for the UK. Describe the characteristics, sources, and principles of the British Constitution Outlined below is a short description of the characteristics, sources, and principles of the British Constitution, as well as an evaluation of the different opinions or perspectives of the British Constitution. The characteristics, sources, and principles of the British Constitution are well-connected to the old concept of the rule of law, as well as ancient and more modern institutions. The rule of law as a distinct and separate concept is well over a thousand years old. It has legal and constitutional origins in Ancient Greece and Anglo-Saxon England.1 It was the common law of Anglo-Saxon England that had the strongest influence upon the concept of the rule of law, when even the Norman conquest could not stop its ongoing development.2 The fundamental basis of the rule of law is the notion that all members of any society are not above the law of the land, whether they are monarchs, politicians, the nobility, or indeed ordinary people. The rule of law itself is a concept that contends that everybody lives under the same jurisdiction, of the law of their particular land from its rulers and its lawmakers downwards.3 At first appearance the concept of the rule of law seems to be a straightforward one, yet there are disagreements about the exact nature of the ideals at the core of the concept itself. The critique below will thus discuss the extent to which today’s British state reflects the core ideals of the rule of law.4 England was the country, as already mentioned, in which the concept of the rule of law was developed. The concept being influenced by the common law, Magna Carta, and the Bill of Rights of 1688 establishing the notion that the state should uphold the rule of law to protect its citizens, instead of ignoring the law and subjecting the people to their autocratic will.5 Magna Carta was supposed to firmly establish the principle and concept of the rule of law and curtail the power of the state. In reality the monarchy, despite often-repeated claims of accepting the concept of the rule of law, still held considerable power until the 18th century, when the Prime Minister started to make widespread use of the royal prerogative instead.6 The British state regarded the concept of the rule of law as being a reflection of the strength of liberalism both as an ideology and principle as espoused by John Locke and others. Liberalism as a ideological principle within the British Constitution reflected the increasing influence of capitalism, as well as being a result of the legal and political supremacy of Parliament. The House of Commons passed legislation, whilst the House of Lords contained the highest court in the land, all in the name of the monarch whilst representing the people.7 The unwritten constitution meant and continues to mean that whether or not the state keeping to the rule of law in Britain was less clear than in other countries. The lack of a written constitution was considered to be a legal not to mention a constitutional virtue instead of a problem as some legal experts have argued. It was assumed that because the British state has claimed to have adopted the concept of the rule of law for its constitutional, as well as its legal systems that the British government and all its departments in reality accepted and adhered to the notion in full. There are times though when governments have acted in ways that suggested they believed that they were above the rule of law. Generally if government ministers or senior civil servants act in ways that appear to be contrary to the rule of law they will lose their jobs, protecting the government from the legal or political consequences of their actions.8 Providing the political party forming the British government holds a Parliamentary majority in the House of Commons, it theoretically can pass constitutional and legal not to mention politically motivated legislation that might run counter to the rule of law. British governments have on various occasions been accused of only paying lip service to the concept of the rule of law. This concept is known as Parliamentary sovereignty. It is a very important principle within the unwritten British Constitution.9 Detractors of the lack or limited rule of law within the British state as large parliamentary majorities and the powers accorded via the royal prerogative has allowed governments to adopt policies without fully consulting Parliament, the courts, and ignoring the wishes of the general public. Governments with parliamentary majorities have argued that they are carrying out the policies contained within their manifestos, democracy does not always fit in exactly with the concept of the rule of law. The late Lord Hailsham a former Law Lord once described the constitution of the British state as being an elected dictatorship.10 Arguments, as well as debates concerning how the concept of the rule of law affects the legal and the constitutional situation within the British state partially reflect the vagueness and also the ambiguity of the very of the rule of law itself. People with more liberal or more democratic attitudes were not particularly convinced that the British state was not totally committed to the core values within the concept of the rule of law.11 The critics of the contemporary British state argue that the rival political parties have considered the concept of the rule of law and other constitutional principles as being less important than the gaining and maintaining of political power via the winning of general elections. Such critics have pointed out that the combination of an unwritten constitution and the use of the royal prerogative has allowed the British state to bypass the democratic process through the use of dubious though not illegal means whenever it suited British governments to do so.12 However, in many respects Britain’s membership of the European Union has had profound constitutional and legal consequences for the British state when taken as a whole. The British Parliament no longer has the complete legal and political sovereignty with European Union legislation taking priority over domestic laws.13 The European Convention for Human Rights also has the power to make judgements about British laws and the government can change the legislation it considers to be contravening human rights.14 The ways in which the British state reflects the core values of the concept of the rule of law has undoubtedly changed 1997.15 The New Labour government was committed to wholesale constitutional and legal changes which have reshaped the British State, thus affecting how the core values of the concept of the rule of law are reflected inside today’s Britain itself.16 In 1997 the outgoing Conservative government had been deeply unpopular in Scotland and Wales due to its economic policies whilst it had governed both countries without any Scottish or Welsh MPs. New Labour was the dominant political party in Scotland and Wales so it was committed to the introduction of devolved government to both countries in order to reduce support for nationalist parties as much as making the British state more responsive to the core values of the rule of law.17 Devolved government has given the voters of Scotland and Wales a greater degree of input into the legal and political decisions that concern their lives. The introduction of devolution also means that the Scottish Parliament and the Welsh Assembly can pursue policies and pass legislation that is different from those implemented in England.18 There is also the possiblity that devolution could to lead to the independence of Scotland at some point in the future, which would literally shrink the British state whilst demonstrating that the democratic will of the Scottish people was not been ignored. Devolved government has also been restored in Northern Ireland as part of the peace process. Power sharing is hopeful sign that there is a return to the normal rule of law after the Troubles had closed down the Storemont Parliament and led to thousands of deaths. Devolution is intended to make the British state more responsive and more representative for all the people of Britain.19 A fundamental shift in the way that the core values of the rule of law are thus reflected in the British state has been witnessed in the area of human rights. New Labour passed the Human Rights Act 1998 in order to protect the human rights of all British people by enshrining the European Convention of Human Rights into the constitution, as well as the legal system.20 The purpose of the Human Rights Act 1998 was to make sure that the British state could not abuse or reduce the human rights of its own people, in other words to comply with the rule of law.21 The Human Rights Act 1998 increased the power of the courts to make legal decisions instead of the Home Secretary using the royal prerogative, for instance for judges to set the maximum term for jail sentences. The Human Rights Act 1998 also made it easier for people to question the decisions of government departments that have adversely affected their lives. Being able to hold the government and its various departments into account is certainly a reflection of core values that mean the British state is abiding by the rule of law. Other legislation such as the Data Protection and the Freedom of Information Act are intended to improve the rights of citizens whilst making the government, officials, and departments more accountable for their actions.22 To conclude today’s British state does to some extent reflect the concept of the rule of law as the government is democratically elected, yet can have its actions scrutinised by Parliament, the media, and the European Convention of Human Rights. The introduction of devolution in Scotland and Wales has made the British state more responsive to the wishes of its component countries and their populations, whilst increasing the risks of the United Kingdom dissolving in the future. The Human Rights Act 1998 is also a reflection of the core values being reflected as the rule of law. However, despite membership of the European Union and the change linked with the Human Rights Act 1998 the British government and its ministers can still wield considerable influence and power. Thus to conclude the combination of an unwritten constitution and the use of the royal prerogative has allowed the British state to bypass the democratic process through the use of dubious though not illegal means whenever it suited British governments to do so. The principles of the rule of law and Parliamentary Sovereignty remain despite membership of the European Union and the legal alterations connected to the Human Rights Act 1998 the British government and its ministers can still wield considerable influence and power. Bibliography Alder J, (2007) Constitutional and Administrative Law, 6th edition, Palgrave, London Breyer S, (2008) Active Liberty, Oxford University Press, Oxford Coxall B, Robins L & Leach R (2003) Contemporary British Politics 4th edition, Palgrave, London Eatwell R & Wright A, (2003) Contemporary Political Ideologies 2nd Edition, Continuum, London Gardiner & Wenborn (1995) the History Today Companion to British History, Collins and Brown Ltd, London MacDonald A, (2007) Reinventing Britain, Constitutional change under New Labour, Politico’s, London Martin E A, (2003) A Dictionary of Law, Oxford University Press, Oxford McCormick, (2002) - Understanding the European Union, Palgrave, London Nugent N, (2003) The Government and Politics of the European Union 5th edition, Palgrave, London Parpworth N, (2004) Constitutional and Administrative Law, Butterworths, London Young H, (2003) supping with the Devils – Political writing from Thatcher to Blair, Guardian Books, London Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Contemporary British Politics and Contemporary Political Ideologies Essay, n.d.)
Contemporary British Politics and Contemporary Political Ideologies Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/politics/1718064-prime-minister-has-suggested-that-some-of-his-power-under-the-royal-prerogative-should-be-transferred-to-parliamentthis-has-led-for-renewed-calls-for-a-written-constitution-for-the-uk-describe-the-characteristics-sources-and-principles-of-the-british
(Contemporary British Politics and Contemporary Political Ideologies Essay)
Contemporary British Politics and Contemporary Political Ideologies Essay. https://studentshare.org/politics/1718064-prime-minister-has-suggested-that-some-of-his-power-under-the-royal-prerogative-should-be-transferred-to-parliamentthis-has-led-for-renewed-calls-for-a-written-constitution-for-the-uk-describe-the-characteristics-sources-and-principles-of-the-british.
“Contemporary British Politics and Contemporary Political Ideologies Essay”. https://studentshare.org/politics/1718064-prime-minister-has-suggested-that-some-of-his-power-under-the-royal-prerogative-should-be-transferred-to-parliamentthis-has-led-for-renewed-calls-for-a-written-constitution-for-the-uk-describe-the-characteristics-sources-and-principles-of-the-british.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Contemporary British Politics and Contemporary Political Ideologies

Changes in the UK Social Policy since 1945

hellip; In the United Kingdom (UK), there are several historical and contemporary landmarks in social policy.... There are 2 major influences on the development of social policy: firstly, ideologies – differing ideologies from those of William Beveridge in the post-War period to those of scholars in the course of the post-War era who critiqued Beveridge to contemporary social policy analysts and intellects have served to shape and broaden the concept of social policy in the UK....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The British Press Market

Even when there is partial parallelism, political ideologies are mirrored in the media: dominant political views dominate the press, and less dominant ones (or opposition parties) have little opportunity to challenge the status quo.... (Negrin 52) It gives a plausible explanation of the intimate relationship between politics and print, and it also explains how the system reproduces itself.... The paper "The British Press Market" analyzes that since the abolition of the Star Chamber Court and the abandonment of press licensing in 1695, as well as the 1792 Fox's Libel Act and the 1843 libel reforms, the British press was now believed to be independent of state's political....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Separation of Powers Exists within the British Political System

Ever since, one of the implicit conditions of this outcome was that the judges should take care not to encroach on the legitimate spheres of discretion of the sovereign political authorities, Crown and Parliament.... It is notable that unlike others entities the Crown is not subject to legal regulation due to the sense of dignity it evokes....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Roles and Powers of the United States Congress and the British Parliament

In order to achieve this objective, this essay will first highlight and identify some of the history… After this point this essay will identify the roles and powers of each body in order to provide some of the differences and similarities between each unit According to Heywood (2003) political ideas and ideologies can act as a kind of social cement, which in turn could provide social groups with a set of unifying beliefs and values.... The purpose of this essay is to provide a deep analysis of the differences and similarities of the roles and powers of the United States Congress and the british Parliament....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

What Are the Main Features of British Conservatism

However, its political and ideological significance can barely be identified owing to a number of reasons.... Secondly, there exists an internal heterogeneity in the political philosophy of conservatism that entails a number of aspects but is summarized under one feature that is the stabilization and justification of strong social structures.... One focuses on the opposing political trends and forces while the other focuses on the preservation of the social structure in its original form....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Aftermath of World War I

The nature of the treatment become more integral part of the cultural heritage and later changed the cultural expectation and behaviors in Britain and FrancePolitical level The legal evidence point to the fact that the world war 1 impacted to a larger extent the political considerations of the administrative set up in contemporary british and French nations.... Most notable was the impact was in cultural values such as traditional ideologies.... Psychological disorders such as shell shock were common with various allies particularly the british and French....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Social Policy in Britain

he ideologies of Social Democrats are equality of all people in a state both socially and economically and establishing a socialist and fair system of governance (Hattersley, Hickson 2013, p.... The New Right bases its ideologies on the opposition of liberalism, egalitarianism, and democracy.... The war is identifiable because it caused major economic, political, and social changes in Britain.... The war is identifiable because it caused major economic, political, and social changes in Britain....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Can We Have a Universal Common Identity

discusses the concept of Universal Common Identity from a Philosophical viewpoint, outlining the key issues, concepts, and central debates that define the theme, relating the issues, areas of contemporary political philosophy.... his paper tries to study the concept of Universal Common Identity from a Philosophical viewpoint by briefly outlining the key issues, concepts, and central debates that define the theme, relating the issues, concepts, and debates identified in the relevant areas of contemporary political philosophy as articulated in Adam Swift's Political Philosophy text, and evaluating the relative strong points and limitations of the different perspectives of the theme....
9 Pages (2250 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us