StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Poor Public Image of Lawyers - Coursework Example

Cite this document
Summary
"The Poor Public Image of Lawyers" essay discusses the popular image of lawyers and the legal profession across the globe and explores why this image does not always conform to the highest standards. This essay explores the extent to which the image of lawyers reflects the reality of their function. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.6% of users find it useful
The Poor Public Image of Lawyers
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Poor Public Image of Lawyers"

The Poor Public Image of Lawyers The legal profession has attracted some of the most highly regarded individuals in contemporary history, including notable statesmen like Sir Thomas Moore, Abraham Lincoln, Nelson Mandela and Bill Clinton. However, few will deny that the profession also suffers from a poor public image. This essay will discuss the popular image of lawyers and the legal profession across the globe and explore why this image does not always conform to the highest possible standards. As popular perceptions do not always reflect reality, this essay will explore the extent to which the image of lawyers reflects the reality of their practice, attitude and function. Finally, some light will also be shed on what steps have been taken to improve the poor public image of lawyers, and what more requires to be done. When the Gallup Organisation conducts its annual survey of professions, the American public consistently ranks nursing as the most honest and ethical profession. Other medical professions are also highly regarded. The legal profession, on the other hand, finds itself close to the bottom of the list- after car salesmen, HMO managers, insurance salesmen, advertising executives and stockbrokers! Indeed, only 16% of all those surveyed rate the honesty and ethics of lawyers as ‘high’.1 There is perhaps no singular reason for this poor public image, but is rather based on a collection of some misconstrued facts about lawyers and the work they do. One factor that contributes to the poor public image of lawyers is the hefty salary many of them take home. With six figure salaries not being uncommon amongst lawyers in the UK and around the world, they are perceived as greedy and gluttonous. While lawyers have generally been generously paid, it is only in recent times that law firms’ profit and lawyers’ salaries are published for all to see.2 Resentment of the privileged in society is not uncommon, especially when they are not seen to give back enough through charity or pro bono work. A related cause of the poor public image of lawyers is the limited availability of Legal Aid funding.3 Indeed, the high fees charged by lawyers deny many of the less privileged access to quality legal advice and representation in the absence of some form of public funding. However, not only is this funding limited, but it also fails to guarantee access to the most competent lawyers- many who undertake legal aid work are underpaid and therefore under-committed to their clients. This contributes to the perception of lawyers as uncaring and driven by money alone. Another related complaint against lawyers is that they are always pressed for time, perhaps seeking to make as much money in a day as possible. As a result they rarely return calls and avoid meeting their less lucrative clients.4 Lawyers are commonly referred to as ‘opportunistic’, looking to profit from other people’s misfortunes, accidents and difficulties. This perception is fuelled by regular advertisements by personal injury lawyers offering no-win-no-fee services to entice potential clients. Indeed television advertising went from near-zero in the 1970’s to hundreds of millions of dollars worth today.5 As advertising soared, so did public perception of the profession. Unfortunately for the profession, this perception was often focused on the personal injury sector – one, which might be considered as being more opportunistic than others. The volume of personal injury litigation has been increasing ever since and it is no longer unheard of for a person to sue a major company over spilled coffee or a public house over a slip on their premises. It is unsurprising that the public views this frivolous litigation as a colossal waste of court’s time and money. In fact, Stephen Byers, a former Cabinet Minister, has complained that schools pay the equivalent of 8000 teachers’ salaries a year towards compensation and that the increase in the cost of claims against the NHS since 1974 could have paid for 22,700 new nurses. Local authorities have been forced to increase council tax to cover the cost of compensation payouts and the NHS is said to be buckling under the strain of litigation.6 With lawyers undertaking and perhaps even encouraging such litigation, it should come as no surprise that they suffer from a poor public image. People more often come into contact with a lawyer at a difficult time- perhaps during serious financial or family problems, or after being accused of a crime. Thus they are likely to harbour negative feelings towards them by association. Furthermore, litigation is often a zero-sum situation- one either wins or loses.7 There is, therefore, always the possibility that a losing party will become upset and blame his/her lawyer for the loss, even if the lawyer is not at fault. Lawyers owe a strict duty of confidentiality to their clients and must strive to achieve a successful outcome for their case. Lawyers also have to be morally neutral while they deal with clients- it is not our job to judge or criticise. Defendants in a criminal trial owe the same duties to their lawyers as the victim. However, many people see criminal defence lawyers as ‘immoral’, ‘opportunistic’ and worse as people who put the wider society at risk by facilitating an acquittal for a suspected murderer or rapist.8 Incidentally, criminal trials make for sensational television and are widely followed by the public, reinforcing the negative image of defence lawyers. For example, during the O.J. Simpson trial in the United States of America, defence attorney Johnny Cochran was widely blamed for what the public considered to be a miscarriage of justice. Many people complain of the law being too complicated and their rights too obscure and difficult to discover. Indeed a major part of modern legislation is incredibly long and technical and even the best of lawyers and judges struggle with its interpretation. The legal profession is often saddled with the blame for such complexities. This fuels the perception of lawyers as being manipulative. Another significant cause of the poor public image of lawyers is their poor depiction in the media of popular culture such as film, television and books. Prior to the 1980’s, the vast majority of lawyers in film were portrayed very positively. There was Atticus Finch in To Kill a Mockingbird, Henry Drummond in Inherit the Wind and Paul Biegler in Anatomy of a Murderer. However, more recent movies have portrayed lawyers in less than flattering light. In The Verdict, for example, the plaintiff’s lawyer is a drunk who solicits business at funerals and impedes a malpractice case coming to trial. The defence lawyer attempts a number of dirty, unethical tricks and even attempts to bribe a witness. The examples of such characters in modern films are numerous. On television, the likes of Denny Crane on Boston Legal often make a mockery of the law. Things are not always any better in print either John Grisham’s widely read novels depict lawyers as greedy, dishonest scoundrels. This harsh treatment of lawyers and the legal profession in the media of popular culture moulds public perception. Psychological studies of the ‘cultivation effect’ show that in making quick judgements, people draw heavily on what they see and learn from film or television. Of course, this can work both ways- research shows that people who watched L.A. Law, a television series in which lawyers were portrayed in a positive, almost heroic light, had a more favourable opinion about lawyers than those who did not.9 While there is no doubt that lawyers suffer from a poor public image, the extent to which this image reflects the realities of the profession is more debatable. For example, although a common perception is that personal injury lawyers have, through advertising, contributed to an increase in frivolous litigation, in reality the number of personal injury claims has fallen in recent years. The Compensation Recovery Unit records indicate that while in 2003-2004 there were over 770,000 claims, this number fell to under 675,000 in 2005-2006.10 The image of lawyers as greedy individuals who do not give back to society may also be misjudged. Many large firms in the UK dedicate considerable resources to pro bono activity and the Advocates for International Development, based in the UK, coordinates large firms’ efforts to contribute to international development and poverty relief. 11 Nonetheless, misconceived or not, the poor public image of lawyers persists and this essay will now turn to the issue as to what can be done to counter this negative image. Bar associations across the world have already taken steps to counter the poor public image of lawyers. For example, in 2007, the Pennsylvania Bar Association began tackling the issue through three commercial campaigns that ran on popular television. The 30 second spots included a woman praising a lawyer for assistance in adopting a child; a man talking about how a lawyer protected the legal rights of his father suffering from Alzheimer’s; and a woman describing how her lawyer helped her secure a loan for a greenhouse business.12 Such adverts are intended to counter the image of lawyers as uncaring and driven solely by monetary considerations. The cost of placing such adverts is significant though and not all Bar Associations have found them effective. Writing from Michigan, Kimberly Cahill stated that there was little change in the image of lawyers after positive advertisements were run.13 No doubt, more can be done to improve the image of lawyers and the legal profession. Legal ethics could be included in all major courses at law school and more law firms could set a minimum number of hours to be spent, by each lawyer, on some form of pro bono activity. Furthermore, firms could place a greater emphasis on etiquette and training the lawyers to deal with all clients, lucrative or not, in a polite and attentive manner. More importantly, younger lawyers must be taught that there is a difference between zealous advocacy and boorish behaviour that puts clients off. To conclude, the nature of a lawyer’ occupation and remuneration is unlikely to place them amongst the most widely liked class of society. Proper training, more charity work and comprehensive ethics education may improve this poor public image, but it would be naive to expect too much of an improvement. Lawyers in the UK are well paid and will never attract popular affection in the same way that a charity worker or a nurse might do. In the eyes of popular opinion, lawyers sit near the top of the capitalist hierarchy, and whilst they may widely be respected as individuals, they will always find it difficult to be loved as a group. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(The Poor Public Image of Lawyers Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 words, n.d.)
The Poor Public Image of Lawyers Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 words. https://studentshare.org/professional/1730387-poor-public-image-of-lawyers
(The Poor Public Image of Lawyers Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words)
The Poor Public Image of Lawyers Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words. https://studentshare.org/professional/1730387-poor-public-image-of-lawyers.
“The Poor Public Image of Lawyers Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words”. https://studentshare.org/professional/1730387-poor-public-image-of-lawyers.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Poor Public Image of Lawyers

Coors: A Move into the UK Brewing Industry

These factors, which gives alcoholic products bad image in the society to the detriment of manufacturers, can be overcome by a more aggressive and intensive effort which primarily includes the health benefits of beer.... nbsp; It should also be noted that there are negative connotations given to beer such as being “a chemical product in factories, session drink, unhealthy drink, poor partner for food, and a male drink....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

The Paralegal Profession

With flexible working hours, more-than-competitive salaries and a wide range of legal fields in which to work, the legal profession is among the… st professions that hard working, intelligent, legal-minded students can choose, as they prepare to take that big step out of college and into the workforce. In today's career pool, lawyers are among the most-needed and highly paid individuals, especially those who have lawyers who handle high profile, media-friendly cases gain the distinct advantage of demanding higher pay and accolades, particularly those who win more cases than their peers....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Euro RSCG Worldwide Named Largest Global Advertising Agency

One of the main objectives, it seems, of advertisers is to create a positive brand image by making one product stand out from other competing products.... Essentially, the senior level adman/adwoman must know their market environments and be ready with advertising tactics which will give the best image to the particular product brand.... Because there is so much linkage between brand image, company image and the needs of consumers, a positive public relations person who can deal effectively with different social groups would be vital in a globally-minded ad agency....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Devices employed in Current affairs Program and the News Program

As this is done, the image of Ms.... The moments after the jury left the room, she went about hugging her lawyers tightly while she sobbed.... This paper highlights that the evolution of the world has been accompanied by various developments, which touch on changes that have taken toll on information and communication....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Criminological Theory

He takes note that there is a greater possibility of individuals who are in the lower bracket of income to be arrested for petty crime in comparison to their counterparts in the higher… It is notable that numerous studies and research has indicated that there is a bias in the arrest rate of individuals in the lower brackets....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

Brand Planning for HMV Company

Brand management is what distinguishes product or services produced by a certain company from other despite the fact that the services of products might all be the same and meant to serve the same… Brand usually represents a business organization and what they stand for.... Through brand management a company can increase their competitiveness by focusing on their strengths....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Brand Plan and Challenges HMV

There are a number of challenges that the company has been experiencing in operation of operations in the UK lately.... These challenges have a direct effect on the growth… During the fiscal years of 2008 and 2009 the company experienced a financial burden.... An increase in production cost has also affected the production volume, meaning that the sales volume has to be low too (Luther 2001, p....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

The Issue of Moral Compass

From the paper "The Issue of Moral Compass" it is clear that leaders and people that are in public or high offices should serve as an example to society in terms of their moral behavior and them taking responsibility for their actions rather than society forcing them to do so.... hellip; Palmer showed remorse for having an extramarital affair, which was wrong in the eyes of the public as he offers an apology to the people that he served and to his People's Action Party....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us