StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Animal Rights Analysis - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
the author states that the treatment of animals should be based on general moral rights and rules, but human life and human existence should be the core of moral decision-making. The author also compares the Web Sites which discuss the problem of animal rights and the treatment of animals. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.1% of users find it useful
Animal Rights Analysis
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Animal Rights Analysis"

Animal Rights According to animal rights, all non-human beings have a right to possess their own lives. Life means that there are some situations where it is immoral to kill an animal, but there are some cases when it is morally permissible to do some things to non-human animals that would be immoral to do to a human being. Critically, when a society strikes that balance between these competing interests and characterizes that balance as a moral right it is the balance which is fundamental: The fundamental right of the animal to be protected against violent treatment and killing.

Within the animal rights movement, every animal, from conception to natural death, has a certain value given by God. The second strand employs the arguments from the field of legal philosophy, specifically natural law, claiming that the right-to life is a fundamental right which should be protected by law. On the other hand, if an animal and its existence threaten human life, it is morally permissible to kill this animal: for instance, outcasts with rabies, extreme aggressiveness of an animal or invasion of animals such as wild foxes or wolves.

Also, gene engineering and cloning need sacrifices in order to protect human live and find treatment for incurable diseases. Also, all medicines and treatment methods are tested on animals to be sure that they are safe for human beings. In this case, it is morally permissible to do these things to non-human animals. This balance is an expression, then, of core values, of basic societal choices. This is the point where the distinction between rights and boundaries collapses since Moral rights- beyond the core-become an expression of the kind of particularized societal choice of which fundamental boundaries are an expression.

Moral boundaries are designed, thus, to allow communities to make and live by those differing balances which they deem fundamental. In sum, treatment of animals should be based on general moral rights and rules, but a human life and human existence should be the core of moral decision-making. ReferencesNussbaum, M.C., Sunstein, C.R. (2004). Animal Rights: Current Debates and New Directions. Oxford University Press. Compare and Contrast of the Web SitesBoth web sites discuss the problem of animal rights and treatment of animals.

The main similarity is in perspectives they are written from. Both web sites UUFETA (Unitarian Universalists for the Ethical Treatment of Animals) and Animal Freedom are based on religious perspectives incorporating moral and ethical point of view. Both web sites state that the community should always seek to adopt the highest standard of animal rights around. Both sites agree that the voice of one individual in a modern society will normally carry little weight unless the demands which that individual articulates come from within the central elite and its decision-making body until those concerned get together with others who share a common interest and aggregate their demands into a program for action.

UUFETA argues that "We recognize that our relationship with animals reflects how we deal with the environment" (UUFETA 2006). In contrast, Animal Freedom discusses different views on the problem based on ethical values and importance of animals for human beings. They underline that "the Catholic Church'' says it is legitimate for humans to use animals for food and clothing, and to domesticate them for work or leisure" (Animal Freedom, 2006). Also, it is often asserted in the regulatory area that decision-making creates the danger of wrong interpretation of the law.

Its yardstick for scrutiny must be "up to standard"-the moral standard. Both web sites are aimed to protect rights of animals but it seems Animal Freedom is more objective and impartial than UUFETA. UUFETA follows the maximalist approach which goes even further since, it is argued, while it would satisfy the legal order, it would not dissatisfy the other legal orders. Animal Freedom shows that the maximalist approach does not work, cannot work and, for good reason, has been rejected by the many moralists.

They state that animals should be protected from aggressiveness and brutality, but it is important to remember that human life is the highest value we have. References1. UUFETA. (2006). Retrieved from http://www.uucb.org/UUFETA/ 2. Vatican official calls for more just relationship with animals. (2006) Animal Freedom. Retrieved from http://www.animalfreedom.org/english/column/vatican.html

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Animal Rights Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Animal Rights Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/social-science/1499106-animal-rights-college-essay
(Animal Rights Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Animal Rights Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1499106-animal-rights-college-essay.
“Animal Rights Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1499106-animal-rights-college-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Animal Rights Analysis

Recreational Hunting: An immoral Violation of Animal Rights

As is evident, therefore, both camps have diametrically opposed perceptions of the ethics of recreational hunting, with the controversy essentially coming down to the anthropocentrism doctrine versus that of animal rights.... While one may concede to the fact that the proponents of recreational hunting have raised a number of valid points in defence of their stance, the fact rema ins that recreational hunting is little other than a cruel blood sport which is ultimately predicated on the erroneous assumption of man's dominion over nature, on the one hand, and the fact that animals do not have rights, on the other....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Animal Rights

This literature review "animal rights" puts under the examination the following articles: “Why Worry About the Animals?... Rational analysis suggests this could be interpreted as a misrepresentation of references, as the statements stand-alone without contextual support.... As such, it comes across as rhetorically authoritative and sets out to convince the reader that "the moral case rests both on the goods to be realized, the evils to be avoidedthereby, and on the duty to respect persons and to secure them in their natural and moral rights....
7 Pages (1750 words) Literature review

An Analysis of the Animal Rights Debate from an Ethics Perspective

Peter Singer, who played a pioneering role in the founding of Animal Liberation Movement, posits strong argumentative tactics that vindicate his convictions in his… Angus Taylor, a faculty member of the Department of Philosophy in University of Victoria, uses instances from the general life of human beings and animals to theoretically persuade the cause of animal rights in the essay “Nasty, Brutish, and Roger Scruton's “The Moral Status of Animals” follows a similar line of argument that defends all life forms on the face of the earth and reveals his intense convictions in ideological and environmental thought....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Analysis of An Animals Place Article by Michael Pollan

“What this suggests to me is that people who care should be working not for animal rights but animal welfare -- to ensure that farm animals don't suffer and that their deaths are swift and painless.... In a profound investigation of the arguments of people who plead for animal liberation, the author maintains that the most difficult animal rights challenge is posed by the killing of animals for meat and clothing.... Section 4: Discussion about vegetarianism and animal rights....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Peter Singer's All Animals are Equal

Singer begins by making relations between the animal rights struggle and people's rights struggles.... Singer references to the prejudices and hates that exist among humans, then referencing their rights struggle, and extrapolating it to animals.... rdquo; (Singer, 1989) In my opinion, Singer would better communicate his point if he preached on the necessity of compassion for animals, but in this instance, he suggests a quality of rights with humans....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Animal Rights

This paper ''animal rights'' tells that A propagation of contemplation insisting that all the animals have a right to live their own lives and they should be safe from human cruelty and brutality.... This research paper will demonstrate in which sectors particularly the violation of animal rights is enlarged, the outcomes of this brutality and its impact on the environment.... This scenario is certainly creating immense problems for animals as their rights are violated immensely....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Wildlife Management and Animal Rights

They have a great role that they play in the… The debate has even led to a strong group that advocates for the animal rights and even condemning their use for human benefits. However, the aspect of animal rights and welfare issues is a subject to debate and analysis.... Those animal rights Affiliation Animal RightsThe debate on animal welfare and animal rights has shown great interrelationships over a number of years....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Testing on Animals

These oppose claim that the animals, though living in the wild, have rights too.... It would be of great importance to note from the onset that animal testing does not necessarily mean that the animal has to be killed.... Some forms of animal testing only involve the observation of animalanimal testing is sometimes referred to as animal research, animal experimentation or in-vivo testing....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us