What makes Romeo and Juliet a Tragedy and who or what is to blame
Many people see a tragedy as an abrupt regrettable occasion, which leaves individuals sad, upset and possibly grieving. A Shakespearian disaster is very different. A Shakespearian disaster needed to have more than one unfortunate event leading up to one major awful occasion. The audience needs to feel pity, worry and a sense a waste of life. A Shakespearian disaster is brought about by fate and inevitability, it likewise has a main big subject usually love or greed. The main tragedy of Romeo and Juliet is they pick eliminate themselves rather then live their lives apart.
It is likewise a disaster as there is such a terrible waste of life, Juliet was just thirteen and Romeo was in his early twenties. I do not think that there is one specific individual or thing that was accountable for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet. I feel that it was combination of aspects that are accountable for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet. The primary aspects I feel were; Fate, the Feud, the nurse, Old Capulet and Friar Laurence. An Elizabethan would have blamed fate for the loss of the young fans’ lives.
They thought that fate was like a wheel of fortune, in some cases you were on the leading however as simple for the wheel to turn and you could be at the bottom. Fate likewise implied that it was going to occur no matter what obstructed, this was the case in Romeo and Juliet. Romeo and Juliet’s fate was found even prior to they were born as it was written in the stars. Although fate traps Romeo and Juliet by their fatal defect, many things happen to their misery and is not their fault. For example, the letter sent by the Friar does not reach Romeo by a random occurrence.
Second of all, fate puts Romeo and Juliet in opposite Houses and therefore puts their relationship under jeopardy. Nevertheless, there is a conflicting side to fate. Romeo and Juliet made their own options through out the play. Romeo goes to the Capulet ball despite his premonitions and understanding that Capulet is bitter enemy. Juliet chooses when she discovers that Romeo is her bitter enemy she has the possibility to end her relationship. Although they make their decisions they may have been under the influence of ‘True’ love and this could have been a series of unfortunate coincidences.
This connects to Shakespeare’s idea of a disaster where a disaster was not one significant unfortunate occasion however a series of regrettable occasions or coincidences. The first lines of the prologue tell us about the hate and envy between the 2 homes. “Two homes, both alike in self-respect … From ancient animosity to brand-new mutiny” Prologue, 1-3. No leader of either family ever though about making peace, they were all too busy to spoil whatever for the competing family. This made it impossible for Romeo and Juliet to have an open relationship, which made them have to go around in trick.
They were forced to keep this trick to themselves and the nurse and they were not allowed to talk or see each other in public. The feud indicated that Tybalt was instantly up for a battle whenever he saw a Montague this did not help Romeo and Juliet with their issues. Also the fact that it was “wrong” for Romeo and Juliet to be together made them more powerful and going to do all the could to be together in life or death. The Nurse’s name is Angelica. I does not fit her as she is somewhat two-faced and she stopped working Juliet by not supporting her choice to remain married to Romeo.
When Juliet initially informs the Nurse of her love for Romeo, she is thrilled and motivates Juliet and assist with preparations for the wedding event. In Act 1 scene 4 the Nurse agrees to be the messenger to Romeo as she likes and wishes to get associated with the relationship. After Romeo’s banishment and Tybalt’s death the turn Nurse turns on Juliet and takes Tybalt’s side as she is part of the Capulet family and Tybalt was Juliet’s cousin and understands blood is thicker than water. The Nurse tells Juliet to wed Paris after Romeo’s banishment which is bigamy and a sin and Elizabethan’s were very religious.
The Nurse fails Juliet in Act 3 scene 5 as she safeguards Juliet when her daddy is screaming at her to wed Paris then she inform Juliet to Paris. Capulet is accountable for the death of the young fans as he fails Juliet and opposes what he states about her marriage to Paris. First of all, in the play Capulet feels that he should wait a couple of years up until Juliet and Paris know each other correctly. “Let 2 more summertimes with her in their pride, here we may think her ripe to be a bride-to-be.
” Capulet likewise feels that he needs to offer time for Paris to win Juliet’s heart. But charm her, mild Paris, get her heart.” Nonetheless, Capulet alters his mind about Juliet and Paris’ marital relationship and move it forward when he was determined to wait two summers. The moving of the wedding suggested that it offered the Friar less time to get the letter to Romeo. In Act 3 scene 5 Capulet threatens to disown Juliet if she does not go to the church. “Get thee to church a’ Thursday, Or never ever after look me in the face.” In addition to frightening and distressing Juliet, it made her more identified to be with Romeo no matter what she had to do to be him.
This is revealed when she is considering killing herself if Friar Laurence can not help her. “I’ll to the friar, to understand his remedy: If all else stop working, myself have power to die.” Act 3 scene 5. Friar Laurence’s actions throughout played part in the crossed enthusiasts’ death. He married the enthusiasts, which started the dreadful occasions in the play. Friar Laurence said to Romeo: “In one regard I’ll thy assistant be. For this alliance might so delighted show, To turn your households’ rancour to pure love.” Act 2 scene 3 line 86-88.
When he states this, he is mentioning he will assist Romeo by spoiling the 2, due to the fact that through the marital relationship their households might find out to like each other and end the fight. However, he did not think about the repercussions of this and the fact that an ancient animosity could not be dealt with in one day by marital relationship. A second factor the Friar is partly responsible is the fact that he offered Juliet a treatment in order to ‘phony’ her death. Friar Laurence informs Juliet “Take thou this vial, being then in bed, And this distilled alcohol beverage thou off.
When currently through all thy veins shall run, A cold and drowsy humour, for no pulse, Shall keep his native development, but surcease.” Act 4 Scene 1 line 93-97. In this quote Friar Laurence is informing Juliet to take the vial and to drink it when she goes to sleep. This fluid (while going through her veins) will make her cold and sleepy and make it look like if she does not have a pulse. However, her blood will continue moving naturally and will not stop. If the Friar had not offered her the vial, Romeo would not have actually heard the news that she was dead and have killed himself in Capulet’s burial place.
Another reason for the Friars responsibility is the truth that Romeo did not get the information about the plan. None of these elements on their own were responsible for the death of Romeo and Juliet but assisted contribute to the catastrophe. Nevertheless, since they were all taking place at the exact same time they resembled pieces of the jigsaw puzzle, alone they are small and unimportant however assembled in the right way you have a big end result. The main point that makes Romeo and Juliet a disaster is the waste of two young lives.
There is a sense of waste of life as there are a great deal of ‘what ifs’ during the play; what if Romeo had not gone to the ball?, what if Juliet had stood up to Old Capulet about her wedding to Paris?, What if Friar Laurence had not consented to wed Juliet and Romeo and then Juliet and Paris? and so on. In conclusion, from the very start, the love of Romeo and Juliet was destined to be ruined. It is terrible that both these individuals had to pass away. There were scenarios throughout the course of their lives that led up to their deaths.
If their parent’s had not been feuding and if the Nurse had not betrayed Juliet, the outcome of this story would have been different, but fate might not be changed. Nevertheless, I feel that the deaths of Romeo and Juliet are Friar Laurence’s fault due to the fact that of his spontaneous behaviour and the choices he made. His first incorrect action was weding Romeo and Juliet knowing that Juliet was to marry Paris, this started the horrible occasions in the play. The Friar’s 2nd mistake was giving Juliet the vial which he did not personally send a letter informing Romeo of their plan as he assured Juliet.